Some user reviews I think are very representative of how I feel BattleForge is;
Well this game is decent if you're 7 years, but in terms of PVP RTS fails miserably. I mean, no fog of war in pvp. Enough said. Moving ....
The action of the mission of the cooperative is where this game is less, but the gameplay value to fall a lot and gets repetitive after a while. If PVP was fog of war (can not see the map and other actions of player), then the game would be much better in my opinion, but you can always see what your opponent is doing ... What is the point?
The graphics are good, DX11 is always an advantage.
Some minor graphical issues here and there.
What really drives me crazy about this game is the way to get new cards in this game. You can not get new cards to play in cooperative mode or in pvp. You can get "improvements" to the cards you already own but can not get new cards to play.
You really need to buy "sets" of the game site to get new creatures and the ability cards. This idea is great if your stupid enough to lose money on the possibility of buying a deck of cards 1 or 2 that did not have before. You could spend more than 49.99 and has all the cards in the game has to offer. So clever way to steal your money I will give them much credit ...
Anyway, this game is good and everything but the way they make you buy the cards and the way the pvp works without fog of war is just down right ... bad. If you're smart just look at another real time strategy, because it does not really offer anything competitive for a smart player could want. This is more like a game for young children who constantly ask their parents for money to spend on imaginary cards in a game.
I have this game BattleForge 3000 points free when I bought an ATI Radeon HD 5970. Would actually paid real money for cards in this game? Of course not.
And
The game is good, is a blend of strategy and ability to adapt to use the cards and trading systems is very competitive and you have to be very innovative to exchange letters and keep up with current prices, which could increase or drop.PvP is very intense as you need to learn how to deal with the cards and how to use the cards effectively.Even provided for Free2Play F2P players can be used to effectively complete many scenarios at the expert level role, if used correctly.
The only drawback is that there is a small player base, as announced recently and did a lot of maps in spite of the improvements for the cards you will play as many times as you like, but players tend to be repetitive. New also is a hard time to understand the game and may envy other players cards without realizing they already have cards for much of the role and the need to work hard for them.
In short: If it is well publicized and have more maps, which will be one more game. Rocky start for new players, a breeze for experienced players.
Let me know if you guys think these reviews are spot on, or not at all correct.